Overview Reviews

Keystone Pizza, located in downtown Caldwell, Idaho, is renowned for its unique and flavorful offerings. Customers rave about the pizza, describing it as "one of a kind" and well worth the journey. Gabriel Montero, a long-time fan, emphasizes its consistency over the years, offering a compelling reason for repeat visits.

In addition to the delicious pizza, Keystone Pizza provides a cozy atmosphere with fast service and a great selection of beers, making it perfect for sports viewing or a casual meal out. Many patrons appreciate the accessible dining options, accommodating everyone from families to solo diners. The staff shines, with reviews highlighting exceptional customer service, even going the extra mile to support happy customers, as seen when Dani Bartrop received a coupon after a mix-up with her order.

  • Highlights:
  • Unique pizza experience
  • Great beer selection
  • Exceptional customer service
  • Convenient downtown location

Overall, Keystone Pizza stands out as a go-to place for pizza lovers seeking quality and comfort.


1
Unique and Irresistible Pizza

Keystone Pizza serves extraordinary pies that transcend the typical chain offerings. Many loyal customers travel long distances to savor these one-of-a-kind flavors, proving the pizza's legendary status in the community.

2
Top-Notch Customer Service

The staff at Keystone Pizza is known for their outstanding service, creating a welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit memorable. Whether it’s quick assistance or accommodating guests' needs, they show a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction.

3
Fun and Family-Friendly Environment

With its cozy interior and various amenities, Keystone Pizza caters to everyone from families to university students. The casual vibe, combined with options like an all-you-can-eat menu and a kids' menu, makes it an ideal spot for both group gatherings and solo dining.

Additional Services & Amenities

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Does not have assistive hearing loop
Service options
Offers kerbside pickup
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Good for watching sport
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
All you can eat
Serves beer
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Salad bar
Serves small plates
Serves vegan dishes
Serves vegetarian dishes
Serves wine
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Counter service
Seating
Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Historic
Crowd
Family friendly
Good for groups
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Good for kids birthday
High chairs available
Kids' menu
Parking
Free parking lot
Paid street parking
Plenty of parking

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Gabriel Montero
Apr 24,2025
5/5
This is a one of a kind pizza. Best damn pizza around. Not your chain type pizza. I travel hundreds of miles to enjoy this pizza. Been eating it for over 30 yrs and it's never changed.
Daniel Uziel Bautista Torres
Apr 22,2025
5/5
Delicious pizza and ok service.I say this simply because they don't go out of their way and go to the tables and aks if everything is good, do you need some more drink because the fountain machine is behind the counter.The other thing is the place is in the downtown area and sometimes gets crowded
Ronnie Soldano
Mar 23,2025
5/5
Stopped in to Keystone and, I kid you not had the best customer service. Heather you rock! Thank you! Breath of fresh air I would recommend to stop in they've got a ton of stuff to do here :-)
Dani Bartrop
Mar 1,2025
5/5
Even after our pizza got thrown away due to us playing too long lol they still gave us a coupon to use since there was only one slice gone. The staff was so kind and working hard!! Thank you!!!
Melvado
Mar 1,2025
5/5
The highlight is their pizza... which is great cuz it's a pizza place... limited straight to the point with the menu with standard pizza, wings and typical sides... Quality was above average, service was fantastic and price was about right for what we ordered...
Corina B Rangel
Feb 18,2025
5/5
Thee best and I love the salad bar variety and very clean
Richard Berghuis
Jan 13,2025
5/5
Had my daughter's birthday party here with 20 guests and everything was perfect. Staff was very professional and food was perfect. And very affordable under 200 for food and drinks. Thanks Keystone Pizza
Ian Juan
Jan 5,2025
5/5
Came in for the first time to get some food before looking at the Christmas lights at Indian creek. The service was quick and friendly. The food reminded me a lot of Idaho pizza but less acidic, I honestly preferred it over Idaho pizza. The cheesy bread stick were great! We also ordered a combo pizza and a pepperoni pizza and both were good. My niece won a stuffed animal from the claw machine and loved the experience.

Leave a Review

Location

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Top Picks for You

Explore Must-Try Eateries

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!